Upon the former defender took over as the club's manager in January, there was little time to settle in. An intense run of games meant a gradual introduction to his group of players was simply not feasible.
Pundits in Spain pointed out the obstacles he would confront, especially managing a dressing room packed with some of soccer's largest egos.
However forging strong relationships with the squad members did not seem to faze the ex- Liverpool full-back.
"It's not something that concerns me greatly," the coach stated at his introductory media appearance.
60 days since, he says those relationships are developing further and the results on the pitch are coming as a result.
Building Relationships
In March, Arbeloa led his team to triumphs against clubs managed by world-class coaches: the Portuguese manager's the Lisbon side, Pep Guardiola's City and the Argentine's Atletico Madrid.
Los Merengues are still four points behind La Liga leaders Barcelona, with a potentially title-deciding Clasico in May, while their European journey proceeds with a last-eight encounter against the German giants.
The team's performances are improving and the relationships between the manager and players are growing.
"I am becoming to know the individuals better and better," commented Arbeloa after Real Madrid's 3-2 victory against local foes Atletico Madrid last week.
"I came in at a moment when I virtually had little time to work with the squad, to see where they operated best, and to see how they gelled with each other."
He conceded the circumstances of his arrival presented fresh difficulties.
"For me, it's difficult to come mid-season and see how the team functions, and that is precisely what has transformed over these two months," he added.
"At present I understand my charges as individuals and footballers, where I can extract the best performance from them, and where I can implement changes."
Praise for Vinicius Jr
A key individual excelling under the new manager is the Brazilian winger.
He has been in the starting lineup for 16 of Arbeloa's 17 matches at the helm, with his scoring rate also improving significantly - he has netted 11 times under Arbeloa, versus registering just six in 27 outings under Xabi Alonso.
Arbeloa has prioritized rebuilding the forward's confidence, pushing him to play freely and express himself rather than constraining him systematically.
"I'm lucky to have Vinicius, he's loved by the supporters. We want to see the Vini who loves the game, who laughs, who dances… that is the player I want to see," he declared in his initial press conference as manager.
That approach differs from accounts of tension under Alonso, with the forward being heard to say "I will quit this team" after being substituted in October's Clasico.
Arbeloa has openly supported him, making clear he is has the total confidence by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He is among the most dangerous footballers, if not number one, in the world today and he represents what a Real Madrid player is," added the manager.
The Brazilian put discussions about his future at the club to one side last off-season but, last week, he stated his desire to stay clear.
"I'm only thinking about this club and staying there for a long time," he informed the media before Brazil's friendly with France.
Valverde Finds His Best Form Again
Fede Valverde's performances has also improved dramatically since Arbeloa took over.
During the tenure of the previous coach, he managed three goals and seven goal contributions from 31 appearances.
Since Arbeloa's appointment, he has started each of the 17 of his games, finding the net seven times and providing five key passes.
A major reason has been a positional shift to his natural place in the center of the park.
Throughout Alonso's tenure, the player at times found it hard to nail down a starting spot in his natural role, being deployed in unfamiliar positions such as right-back.
Although the choice was partly due to injuries to teammates, Valverde's frustration was evident. "I was not made to be a defender," he stated.
But now, back in his preferred position, the midfielder is thriving.
He has netted six strikes in just a 30-day period, including a three-goal haul against City and a winning goal in a 3–2 triumph over Atletico Madrid.
More Players, Greater Possibilities?
The manager's background as manager of the club's B team has made integrating young players into the senior side feel natural, so it was logical to expect him to give up-and-coming players chances.
This was seen particularly when the team played Elche earlier this month and Arbeloa provided opportunities to six youth team players.
A particular individual, in particular, has quickly established himself as one of the manager's most talented proteges.
Being only 18 years and 226 days old, he made history as the youngest player in the team's records to start twice in the Champions League latter stages, surpassing Vinicius' mark by 10 days.
Asked what it meant to see several academy graduates on the field, Arbeloa couldn't hide his joy.
"I think I can be content after a night like tonight," he stated.
"I was just talking to two of them, who were the initial youngsters I coached when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the opportunity to play at the Bernabeu is a dream come true for me."
While the coach might be knowledgeable about the Castilla players, he admits injuries have restricted his exposure